The Arrogance of Now

Each year I prepared for two major wars, the finale if you will, of second semester US History. With a combined sense of dread and anticipation, I led the kids through the causes, and progression of the Civil War (with 10th graders), and WWII (with my Juniors). 

A lifetime of study in these eras, especially Antebellum America, tells an anxious story, as two passionate belief systems came to blows. Sophomores learned that our nation, a democracy born in such promise, plunged into the abyss over America’s original sin, slavery.

Meanwhile, for Juniors, the failures of the uneasy peace that followed WWI shaped a broader corrosion. The world after 1919 disintegrated into deadly factions, underscored by exaggerated entitlement, racial hate, and lust for revenge.

Much like America’s 19th Century plunge into the breach, the 20th Century also debased human life, sliding into scapegoating, unthinkable cruelty, and massacre. This record is hard to face, let alone study. 

Real monsters masqueraded as heads of state; Stalin, Hitler, Mussolini, and the War Lords of Japan. All, to varying degrees, convinced regular people that the “worth” of others was suspect, and targeting civilians an acceptable strategy. Yet, as awful as both conflicts were, it’s hard not to stare, and to hopefully recognize the signs when hate again emerges as a justification for horror.

The heresy of exceptionalism, normalizing violence on the vulnerable, and extremism, unleashed evil on the world. Andersonville Prison, Fort Pillow Massacre, the Rape of Nanking, Bataan, the Warsaw Ghetto, and death camps. More than one a student wondered aloud, how could that happen?

In increments.

These signs are clear again. Those same pre-conditions have resurfaced, right now, here in our communities, states, and nation. 

A white nationalist parade in Charlotte that kills one, where there were “good people on both sides.” Normalized daily murders of people of color, and incendiary rhetoric that ends with an attack on the US Capitol, killing five. All offenses excused and minimized by a once great political party, that has forsaken its moral underpinnings. 

The only difference between the Proud Boys and the Brown Shirts is the Brown Shirts didn’t wear Carhartt and flannel.

This endless playlist has looped over repeatedly, cursed by the “blind arrogance of now.” But dear reader, now is then, and deluded people do not change with time. The descent into barbarity is more predictable than exceptional. 

When reasonable folks are manipulated by the chorus of the Big Lie, the era doesn’t matter. Society inevitably falls into depravity.   

Gail Chumbley is a career history educator, and author of the two-part memoir “River of January,” and “River of January: Figure Eight.” Both titles on Kindle.

3 comments on “The Arrogance of Now

  1. shallenemcgrath says:

    This is really a great article Gail. I did a lot of research and study into the development of racism via colonialism and imperialism. It makes me believe that the factions which rule us even today started when Colonialist and Imperialist rulers started to divvy up the new world expressly for the purpose of profit. They monetized humanity in bulk. That is to say they made if fashionable in the upper echelons of global to society to think of humans as a expendable natural resource -which they called labor. It is interesting that Socialist -(a dirty word in today’s America) -labor movements came about just as you are saying that the world disintegrated into factions. These movements seem to be a backlash to the idea that humans are an expendable natural resource just like every other natural resource in the eyes of those that put trade and income above quality of life. I found this really interesting and highly educational. Thank you.

  2. j. m. gaines says:

    People need to realize that racism, slavery, bigotry, violence, etc., has been a human component from time immemorial. The people who originally settled our continent brought these traits with them. Slavery did not start in the US, it was very big in England, Spain and other European countries. Also, do not forget the Bonded servants that were sent to America to work off their debts. This was just slavery by another name. I wish I was as articulate as Ms. Chumbley. Please keep teaching the young. I still have hope that there will be a change of thoughts.
    Thank you for reading my diatribe. J. M. Gaines

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s